4 Messages
•
116 Points
Goof deletions/additions and trivia edits/deletions declined
I've had couple of my submissions declined and I don't really understand the reasoning:
#250307-162316-044000
Two of the proposed deletions just assume what characters should have done, even if nothing that would support this was mentioned in the episode, one is just factually incorrect as proven by the link I provided.
#250308-095724-833000
Also a factually incorrect goof, basic logic should be enough to understand that pov is limited on the side of the blind eye.
#250308-102835-371000
Another weird assumption that I wanted to delete, the creator of the goof claimed that since there was no large scale immigration from a particular place, no one would be speaking the language of that place, which is simply incorrect, unless there's proof there was no one coming from there (in that case, Mainland China). Its incorrectness is that more highlighted by the fact that the actress herself is a child of Mainland China immigrants and speaks Mandarin.
#250308-162638-395000
There's a lot of 'Character error' goofs that point out that a smart and educated character says something factually wrong, so I don't understand why this one wasn't accepted.
#250309-112248-925000
All were declined as "unable to verify" and I have no clue why, should I include clips of the scenes? Also, the initial one claimed that something that was present in Sherlock Holmes novels was a reference to Bond franchise created decades later, one was factually incorrect but I'm unable to prove it unless someone watched the episode (or at least one scene), and one was submitted for deletion because it nitpicks what's clearly an artistic license and well understood within the world of the show as true.
Can someone help me understood what I did wrong? And maybe recheck the submissions?
Maya
Employee
•
2.8K Messages
•
30.2K Points
1 month ago
2