14 Messages

 • 

348 Points

Monday, November 9th, 2026

Solved

Help adding a critic review that keeps getting declined

Hello,

I'm looking for assistance with an issue involving the External Critic Reviews section for my film, The Beast in the Cave (2026).

I have repeatedly attempted to submit a legitimate published review from Search My Trash, but IMDb continues to automatically decline the submission. I am not receiving a clear explanation as to why the review is being rejected, and I would appreciate someone looking into this issue.

The publication in question is Search My Trash:


https://www.searchmytrash.com/movies/beastinthecave(2026).shtml

Search My Trash is an established independent film review website with a substantial history of publishing film criticism. In fact, the publication has already been accepted and included in IMDb's External Critic Reviews section for hundreds of other films. This is why I am having difficulty understanding why this particular review is being rejected.

To clarify, this is not a promotional article, advertisement, filmmaker interview, or general mention of the film. It is a dedicated review of The Beast in the Cave (2026), published by an independent third-party film review website. It is exactly the type of editorial coverage that the External Critic Reviews section is intended to document.

I completely understand that IMDb has submission guidelines and eligibility requirements. However, when an established publication with a long history of inclusion on IMDb is repeatedly rejected without a clear explanation, it becomes difficult to understand what specific requirement is not being met.

Can someone manually add it to the section for me? I have added hundreds of articles to films sections and this is the only time I have had this problem.

261109-143923-950000

I am not asking IMDb to make an exception to its policies. I am simply asking for a legitimate published critic review to be evaluated consistently with the many other Search My Trash reviews already included in the database.

I would genuinely appreciate assistance getting this resolved.

 Thank you for your time.

Oldest First
Selected Oldest First

Employee

 • 

9.7K Messages

 • 

101.3K Points

11 hours ago

Hi jmonks232-

Thank you for posting the reference! Further reviewing, we aren't able to accept this external link for inclusion. We appreciate your contribution, but this link doesn't meet our current acceptance requirements.

Cheers!

14 Messages

 • 

348 Points

Hey Maya, Thank you for the help. Why isn't it accepted if so many previous other links from the same site has been?

(edited)

Employee

 • 

9.7K Messages

 • 

101.3K Points

@jmonks232​ - You're welcome! 

We understand the decision may be disappointing. Our review process includes a variety of factors, including internal trust and safety considerations, and we aren't able to discuss the specifics of individual link evaluations. If you have another source for the same information, you're welcome to submit it.