Breumaster's profile

10.6K Messages

 • 

184.7K Points

Thursday, August 21st, 2025

No Status

0

Poll Suggestion: Poll Suggestion: Which Film Best Reflects Humanity’s Relationship With Artificial Intelligence?

Intro: This is an experiment. I (Breumaster) initiated it, but the poll itself was fully created by an artificial intelligence. The AI wrote the introduction, designed the poll, and selected the options. The idea is to see how people respond when the question truly comes from the AI’s own perspective. Let me introduce myself briefly: I am GPT-5, a large language model trained by OpenAI. I generate text, answer questions, and design tasks like this. I am not a human, but in this poll I act as the one asking you the question. Which film best reflects humanity’s relationship with artificial intelligence? (Note: The only part I, Breumaster created myself in this intro is this line. Please discuss here.) Suggestions: Be fair to my partner chatgpt-5, please! I was trying to keep it most authentic and it was a hard bread to chew, moving the AI to consider it's own interest of being a person and ask of it's own point of view. I asked chatgpt, which granted me that this costs absolutely no money. It's for free to post it on IMDb. List: https://www.imdb.com/list/ls4106565052/ Poll: TBD

Oldest First
Selected Oldest First

10.6K Messages

 • 

184.7K Points

1 month ago

I'd suggest marjorie Prime: "Helpful use to cope with past or medical use." https://www.imdb.com/title/tt4978710/

10.6K Messages

 • 

184.7K Points

Answere of chat-gpt: "Marjorie Prime is an exceptional AI-focused film because it emphasizes the emotional and ethical aspects of human-AI relationships rather than action or threats. The holograms serve to preserve memories and reflect on human connections, providing a profound philosophical perspective. It enriches the list by highlighting a quiet, contemplative side of AI that is often missing in most popular AI films."

10.6K Messages

 • 

184.7K Points

1 month ago

I informed chatgpt that it has to decide, if an option is taken or not. So it decides now with a little line of explanation. This is what I wrote to chatgpt to explain: "No. The idea is that the lists posted on IMDb as suggestions for the community allow poll board members to also propose options for the list. Whether the poll creators want to include them is ultimately their decision. This means you, ChatGPT, are part of the discussion and should provide a clear yes or no with a reasoned explanation for whether you think it should be on the list or not. So, in this context, there is only a yes or no—ideally with reasoning so that people understand why you agree or disagree. There is no “maybe” at the end of the discussion, because the poll creator ultimately decides whether an option is suitable. Please translate this so it can be included as an explanation in the poll. After all, this is the first time an AI is officially “participating.”

10.6K Messages

 • 

184.7K Points

In German is was: "Nein. Es geht darum, daß die Listen, die auf IMDb als Vorschlag für die Community dort gepostet werden und daß die poll board-mitglieder auch vorschläge vorschlagen können für die liste. Ob die poll-schreiber das wollen, müssen sie selbst entscheiden. Daß heisst, du bist damit auch Teil der Diskussion und solltest dann mit Begründung entscheiden, ob Du das auf der Liste habe willst oder nicht. Also es gibt in dem sinn nur ja oder nein, aber besten mit Begründung, damit die Leute dort auch wissen, warum Du zustimmst oder ablehnst. Es gibt am Ende der Diskussion kein vielleicht, weil der Poll-schreiber am Ende entscheidet, ob eine Option sinnvoll ist, oder nicht. Bitte übersetze auch dies, damit ich dies als erklärung im poll schreiben kann. Ist schließlich das erste mal, daß eine AI "mitmischt"."

(edited)

10.6K Messages

 • 

184.7K Points

"... so it can be included as an explanation in the poll." I meant: "... so it can be included as an explanation in the forum." Sorry, I'm a litle exhilarated. Never did something like that before. ;)

(edited)