Breumaster's profile

9.9K Messages

 • 

177.1K Points

Wednesday, June 15th, 2022

No Status

0

Poll Suggestion: Which Feeling Leads You to a Lesser High Movie Rating?

Intro: We all have our own motives why we rate movies like we do. You saw a movie and feel that it needs a lower rating than the average rating. Which is the most dominant feeling to rate a movie worse than the majority? Tell us here. Suggestions: Movies as examples. Describe a feeling about it why someone would eventually rate it worse. It can be from your point of view or from a supposed point of view thinking of other parts of the audience. It should be a movie with at least 15.000 ratings. Please remember the issue is about the feeling you have or the feeling you can imagine other parts of the audience could have about. It should be credible somehow. I also want to do a colaborate poll with the same issue, but reverse. List: https://www.imdb.com/list/ls565697124/ List: Which feeling Leads You to a Higher Movie Rating? (TBD) Poll: TBD

Oldest First
Selected Oldest First

4.5K Messages

 • 

71.7K Points

3 years ago

I think I'm pretty fair in my ratings, maybe too much fair. Even when defending Cuties (2020), I didn't try boosting its rating to compensate the vote-stuff by saboteurs, I rated it 6/10 as it deserved. When I feel its impossible for me to give a fair rating, I do not rate the film, I put it in my checkins. I did give unfairly low ratings to some films when I thought the filmmakers were searching for it: Jurassic World, Fantastic Beasts, Donkey Skin, all the Monty Python Films. Notice that two of those films (Donkey Skin and The Holy Grail) broke the convention of the fairy tale by making a modernity appear in the last minutes. It isn't a coincidence, yet I didn't have a problem with The Village (2005).

(edited)

9.9K Messages

 • 

177.1K Points

@cinephile​ Even dumbnuts think they are fair in their ratings. (Excluding you, I know you are not a dumbnut). That's what I thought of. It's a thing about feelings according to films. What you mentioned also isn't general truth. You suppose it is like you told, but without any exact proof. That's ok. I told about the user's feelings about, not understandable exact proofable truth. It should be in an understandable range of feelings people could have about, best the feelings the user has about it by her or himself.

(edited)

9.9K Messages

 • 

177.1K Points

I don't know why my text up there was so long. Today I'd rather say: Movies are also a matter of taste for many people. That would have nailed it much better. ;)

9.9K Messages

 • 

177.1K Points

2 months ago

3 years *bump*