erick_5ivf17f186m94's profile

49 Messages

 • 

1.2K Points

Sunday, May 17th, 2020

No Status

6

Bring back the message boards

Can we please have the message board feature back? Often at times I want to ask the community that could recommend me similar movies based on a movie I liked. There's no way to do that any more. There should be a discussion board for each title page , where we can ask viewers for similar movies.

Oldest First
Selected Oldest First

1.1K Messages

 • 

31.4K Points

5 years ago

IMDb will have to find a way to end the raging abuse of the boards before they consider bringing them back. There may be a couple of ways they can do this.(1) Minds.com is experimenting with a new reporting system. When the staff receives a report of abuse, they make the first decision on whether to act on it. A punished user can appeal the decision, which then goes to a group of randomly selected users.The randomness makes the decision likely to be fair. The staff can be biased. An elite group of users who get to make all judgments would be biased and subject to corruption. But a randomly selected group, different every time, would almost guarantee a fair judgment.(2) IMDb could charge for access to the message boards. Trolls and other abusers are less likely to pay than a user who wants to have civil and productive conversations. The few trolls who do pay for entry can be easily managed and removed.

3 Messages

 • 

164 Points

why is twitter or facebook immune from abuse and trolling? The system of peer reporting on the message boards was adequate and not much different from a couple of your ideas. Theaters have closed, we need a message by topic listed only imdb had. Interaction is limited when movies are only being streamed now.

1.1K Messages

 • 

31.4K Points

Bill Graham: Twitter and Facebook are not immune to abuse; but on both platforms you have a lot of control over your experience. On IMDb, you had very little control. One determined troll or group of trolls could ruin your experience.

124 Messages

 • 

2K Points

This is so true. On one of 'my' boards, we had a troll show up who made life MISERABLE for the rest of us. And he had sock puppets, too! So there were multiple accounts being used to destroy this formerly friendly, inviting board. Complaints to IMDb went unheard/not acted on. It got so bad at one point that I opened up a temporary forum on one of my domains, and only my invited friends from the IMDb board could join. We used that for a few months, until the troll and sock puppets finally left...and then, not long afterward, IMDb shut them all down!

10.7K Messages

 • 

226.1K Points

Still, it is hard to ensure a mostly-positive experience for the vast majority of the participants. For some reason, most human beings have some kind of natural inclination to acquiesce to "echo chambers" and confirmation bias, and social media sites are very good at seamlessly re-enforcing the phenomena using the same algorithms that figure out which advertisements to display to which visitors. There are pros and cons for either way. Some of the message boards of IMDb·Com basically ensured that people who might be very much incapable of agreeing on many things they held dear would always cross each others' paths, unless they made use of the "ignore" feature. A nice feature to be sure, but people who rely heavily upon it put themselves in the position of not being able to defend themselves against libel. The complaint system definitely has to be functional and accountable, but we may always wonder how effective it can be when a vast majority of participants of a forum have a new complaint every day or every hour about a fellow participant, whether it is same one as before or a new one, whether the complaint is crucial or frivolous. Then there is the matter of complaints against the arbiters of the system who've grown weary or corrupt, losing impartiality, or who've done everything right but still receive persistent condemnations. So, that's where the automation and farce come into play, in order to install a very flattering dopamine-driven experience tailored to the needs of each user. LOL!

8.7K Messages

 • 

177.8K Points

5 years ago

? ? https://getsatisfaction.com/imdb/topics/imdb-message-boardsIMDb message boards Announcement Col Needham, Official Rep Posted 3 years ago ( Feb 3 2017 )395 Replies- - - https://help.imdb.com/article/imdb/general-information/boards-closure-faq/G5HU888HZYE8LF79#Boards Closure FAQ IMDb.com's message board system closed on February 20th, 2017.The following answers address some of the most frequently asked questions about this transition. - - - Wayback Machinehttp://web.archive.org/web/20170101000000*/http://www.imdb.com/boards/ http://web.archive.org/web/20170220000011/http://www.imdb.com/boards/Message Boards : Feb 20 2017 http://web.archive.org/web/20170219202927/http://www.imdb.com/board/bd0000001/thread/265872671Boards Closure FAQby Col Needham Wed Feb 8 2017 00:00:24.

124 Messages

 • 

2K Points

4 years ago

I miss the message boards SO MUCH! As I recently noted, I had a close-knit group of 'friends' on a couple of boards, and it was devastating when IMDb announced they were shutting them down. Some of us exchanged e-mail addresses, Twitter handles, and so on, and some migrated to a couple of replacements, but it was never the same.

10.7K Messages

 • 

226.1K Points

4 years ago

The cross-domain migration from GetSatisfaction to Sprinklr made me just slightly hopeful that someday there could be a migration back to IMDb·Com. However, there is still a lot of work to be done, if ever there was to be a distinct board to correspond to every IMDb title page. I get the feeling that absolutely under no circumstances would a board specifically designated for politics be brought back before a hundred years after any kind of site-native board would be introduced. Interestingly, a board devoted to such a topic probably only previously existed at all as a place to vent shenanigans that didn't belong elsewhere besides the soap box, the testing board.

6 Messages

 • 

196 Points

2 months ago

Why is that that you ask users to try out the new designs, but never ask for feedback about this or make sure that people actually sees it and can vote, and then that you honor their wishes, should it be voted against. Personally I don't see why some pimpled web designer gets to decide what I like and not even have to option to use the old "theme" which wouldn't be that difficult seeing as how you use CSS and whatnot for other settings, so why not do this for the entire site??? I hate inefficient designs where you have to strain the eyes & brain to find something that's always been there just in sight, always in a specific spot/place and ready to be clicked on. Now these things are hidden away, menus that expands (Like list of movies, directed by etc) that gets reset whenever you back-step a page and you lose your navigation in the list. This forces you to open a new tab/window which should have been the default for such menus instead of using the same window/tab. Inefficient and stupid design! If the list is static you'll have no problems navigating to the next item in the list and it also loads the page faster if no Java scripts or other stuff to render these menus is used, which also means simpler design and less things that can go broken. I say, rid the beautiful site of this "modern" crap and reinstate the old design, and please bring back the forum, but implement CAPTCHA and possibly utilize AI to monitor posts that conflicts with community standards - Now would be the perfect time, and you can no longer say that it would be inefficient to monitor that. This should also be implemented for the reviews since many new movies have fake reviews. In both cases, I think a minimum of x posts should be approved and screened before allowing posting contents, and should any fail to post, manual approval would then be required. I say that if it's considered a good idea to implement A.I. into Swedish JAS 39 Gripen, our top-of-the-line jet fighter (this was on the news in June 2025!), it sure as heck should be good enough to have it run here to help fix the content, and the forum would probably be greater for it too. Note: This comment was created from a merged conversation Link : https://community-imdb.sprinklr.com/conversations/imdbcom/new-designsbring-back-the-forum/684c058b3a61c86440c6372c Title : New designs/bring back the forum

Champion

 • 

7.8K Messages

 • 

279.6K Points

2 months ago

I realize that it's exteremly unlikely that IMDb will ever re-establish the message boards. But I would appreciate it if the staff would confirm that they are pressing Sprinklr to restore functionality to this community. With no active links, no ability to post images, and not even any bold or italic formatting, this board has become a lot less valuable over the last four months.

Employee

 • 

17.9K Messages

 • 

318.2K Points

Hi gromit82 - We are actively working with Sprinklr to restore the previous functionality (richtext, image uploads, hyperlinks, etc.). Unfortunately, I cannot provide an exact timeline, but we are working to reinstate functionality.