Two accounts under same e-mail, can't have my page on PRO

So as the title says, I have two accounts under the same e-mail with different passwords. One account I can login through IMDB and another one through Amazon. The one that I "login with IMDb" has my filmmaker page claimed, the problem is that whenever I want to login to IMDB Pro, I need to do so through Amazon, so it goes to the account that doesn't have my page claimed. I've tried to unclaim my page on the "IMDb" account, but this doesn't seem to work. 

Anybody gone through this? Any suggestions/solutions?

Thanks,

K